Find Hidden Gems in New Jersey Antique Stores
By: Lauren Melville
New Jersey is a living time capsule. While iconic historical moments are safely recorded in books, countless physical mementos are still scattered across New Jersey, waiting for the perfect finder to bring them home. Calling all casual thrifters to serious antique collectors, pick up a little piece of the past at these New Jersey antique destinations.
The Abram Demaree Homestead
Closter
This privately owned 18th century homestead landmark seamlessly blends Dutch and English colonial history with a vibrant modern-day experience. Listed on the National Register of Historic Places, this Bergen County gem functions as a working farm, a cozy café, and a sprawling antique haven. Wander into the massive barn to explore the Vintage Goods and Antique Shop, where you can find timeless treasures across the decades—from vintage jewelry and furniture to retro clothing, books, and art. The Vintage Goods and Antique Shop is open every weekend, 10 a.m.-5 p.m. Fuel up at The Farm Cafe for delicious, light refreshments before you browse. Open Wednesday through Saturday from 10 a.m. to 6 p.m., and Sundays from 10 a.m. to 5 p.m.
Antique Emporium
Asbury Park
@antiqueemporiumasburypark on Instagram
Rainy summer day down the shore? Don’t let a gloomy afternoon ruin your beach trip. Instead, dive into the artifact-filled aisles of the Antique Emporium in Asbury Park. It’s a treasure hunter’s paradise where you can lose track of time gazing at shimmering vintage jewelry, browsing unique glassware, and discovering one-of-a-kind statement furniture. Open seven days a week, 11 a.m.-5 p.m., Sunday 12 to 5 p.m.
Antique Village West Creek
West Creek
Located just off of Long Beach Island, Antique Village West Creek is a treasure trove packed with coastal charm and heavy-hitting nostalgia. Vinyl enthusiasts can lose themselves in crates of vintage records, while interior lovers will find everything from retro kitchenware to antique clocks. But the real showstopper here is the sports memorabilia. You can comb through rare baseball card collections, marvel at original Yankee Stadium blueprints, or even check out the one-of-a-kind Softail Florida Gators motorcycle signed by Tim Tebow and Urban Meyer—originally built to celebrate their national championship wins.
Cape May Antique Center
Cape May
Thanks to its coastal roots, this premier antique destination is a hotspot for unique maritime collectibles and nautical-themed gems. Yet, Cape May Antique Center caters to far more than just sailor gear. With options to fit every budget, shoppers can uncover everything from vintage sheet music and fine jewelry to mid-century to modern furniture and framed stained glass.
The Lafayette Mill Antiques Center
Lafayette
Step back in time at the Lafayette Mill Antiques Center, where history and treasure hunting collide inside a 200-year-old historic gristmill. For more than 45 years, this iconic destination has been a mecca for collectors, showcasing over 50 select vendors offering everything from fine china and artwork to vintage toys and heirloom furniture- you name it, they’ve got it. Need a breather from browsing the multi-level mill? Head next door to the Millside Cafe to recharge with a freshly brewed cup of coffee. Outside the gristmill, the center holds its flea market on the last Sunday of every month from April to October.
Historic Burlington Antiques and Art Emporium
Burlington
Shoppers will find antiques of all kinds at the Historic Burlington Antiques and Art Emporium. Nestled between Philadelphia and New York City, this spot is a wonderland for genuine antiques hailing from all decades. You can spend the day lost among over 65 vendors and dealers, with finds from vintage jewelry to pottery to furniture to home decor across individual booths. Open Sunday through Monday 11 a.m.-5 p.m.
Summit Antique Center
Summit
Since 1990, The Summit Antique Center has curated antiques, vintage art, furniture, collectibles, gifts, props, clothes, silver, toys, and home decor right in Union County. With the help of over 50 experienced dealers and two floors worth, this spot also provides vintage goods from the Victorian era to mid-century modern. Bring a bag, or a U-Haul for your next trip.
Valley Vintage
West Orange
If you prefer a more intimate, boutique shopping experience, Valley Vintage is a quirky joint you have to check out. Curating a tight-knit community of over 20 specialized dealers, it takes the overwhelming guesswork out of antiquing. It’s the perfect spot to hunt for specific hidden gems, from local art pieces and vintage vinyl to retro dishware and prints. Open Monday through Saturday 11 a.m.-6 p.m., Sunday 12-5 p.m.
EXPLORE NORTH JERSEY’S ANTIQUE CAPITAL
Antique lovers, welcome to paradise. Known affectionately as “Andover NJ Antique Row,” this historic shopping district along Main Street in Sussex County is an absolute must-visit. The charming streets are lined with multiple antique shops and multi-vendor collectives, delivering an incredible, ever-changing variety of unique pieces just waiting to be discovered.
Grey Barn Antiques
Tucked away inside a historic old Annex building, Grey Barn Antiques is a local staple featuring over 25 curated vendors. It’s the ultimate spot for tracking down pristine antique furniture, rare collectibles, and nostalgic vintage goods. Can’t make the trip out to Andover just yet? You can still catch their weekly Facebook Lives to sneak a peek at their latest arrivals.
The Andover Village
Nestled right in the heart of Antique Row, The Andover Village serves up a mix of multi-dealer spaces where local history quite literally comes alive. Whether you’re hunting for a rare midcentury relic, estate jewelry, or just some rustic farmhouse decor, this collective offers a sprawling selection that makes the thrill of hunting effortlessly fun. This collection of antique shops is a true village, made up of different locations filled with antique goods inside The 1868 House, The Carriage House, The Cottage, The White House, and The Court Yard, all within walking distance. Shoppers can find outdoor vintage statues, gnomes, and fountains perfect for any garden at The Court Yard or explore The Carriage’s holiday-themed collection. Head to this antique metropolis to find exactly what you’re looking for, open Thursday through Monday 11 a.m.-5 p.m.
Scranberry Coop
A 10,000 sq. foot building, filled with antiques? A dream for antique enthusiasts. Housed in an unmistakable bright yellow building right off Route 206, Scranberry Coop has spent the last 39 years bringing vintage dreams to life. With over 150 vendor booths, it’s packed with everything from rare vinyl records and statement mid-century furniture to quirky trinkets and original art. Don’t miss their outdoor flea markets, hosted on the first Sunday of every month. Open Wednesday through Sunday 10 a.m. to 5 p.m. Good luck walking away empty-handed.